Comparison of Solid Core HPLC Column Performance

Significance of the Topic

High performance liquid chromatography is central to many areas of analytical chemistry, including pharmaceutical development, environmental monitoring and quality control. The emergence of solid-core superficially porous particle columns addresses a key challenge by delivering high separation efficiency while maintaining moderate system backpressure. This balance enables faster analysis, reduced solvent consumption and extended instrument lifetime under routine conditions.

Objectives and Overview of the Study

This study evaluates the chromatographic performance of Thermo Scientific Accucore 2.6 micrometer superficially porous columns relative to competing solid-core products. The comparison focuses on three key parameters: column backpressure as a function of flow rate, separation efficiency reflected in kinetic plots, and overall chromatographic impedance that integrates efficiency, analysis time and pressure.

Methodology and Instrumentation

An HPLC system equipped with UV detection and standard low dispersion hardware was used. All experiments employed 100 by 2.1 millimeter columns packed with 2.6 to 2.7 micrometer solid-core particles. The mobile phase consisted of water and acetonitrile in equal proportions, with column temperature maintained at 30 degrees Celsius. Test analytes included o-xylene and theophylline serving as markers for system dead time. Seven column brands were compared: Accucore, Kinetex, Poroshell 120, Ascentis Express, Halo, Nucleoshell and SunShell.

Main Results and Discussion

Solid-core columns inherently reduce backpressure by limiting pore volume and enhancing permeability. Accucore consistently generated the lowest pressure across the 0 to 1 milliliter per minute flow range, showing a 22 percent advantage over the highest pressure competitor at 1 milliliter per minute. In kinetic plots (Poppe plots), Accucore achieved the fastest plate generation rate, indicating rapid formation of sharp peaks and superior throughput. Regarding impedance, which integrates the effects of pressure drop, dead time and efficiency, Accucore exhibited the lowest values across linear velocities tested, outperforming the next best material by 7 percent and the least favorable by 51 percent.

Benefits and Practical Applications

• Accelerated analysis times without exceeding pressure limits
• Improved peak capacity and resolution in high throughput workflows
• Reduced solvent use and cost per analysis
• Extended lifetime of pumps and fittings due to lower backpressure

Future Trends and Potential Applications

Further developments in superficially porous particle design may lead to sub-2 micrometer solid-core materials, enabling ultrafast separations. Integration with mass spectrometry and microfluidic platforms promises enhanced sensitivity for proteomics, metabolomics and trace analysis. Automated high throughput and online reaction monitoring represent additional areas where these columns can extend analytical capabilities.

Conclusion

Thermo Scientific Accucore superficially porous columns deliver a compelling combination of low backpressure, high separation efficiency and minimal impedance. These attributes make them well suited for demanding HPLC applications where speed, resolution and system robustness are paramount.

References

1. Desmet G, Gzil P, Clicq D. LC GC Europe, 18 (2005) 403
2. Poppe H. Journal of Chromatography A, 778 (1997) 3