Comparison of Optimized Wide Pore Superficially Porous Particles (SPPs) Synthesized By One-Step Coating Process With Other Wide Pore SPPs For Fast And Efficient Separation Of Large Biomolecules

Importance of Topic

Superficially porous particles (SPPs) with wide pores are critical for modern bio-separation methods, offering high efficiency and reduced mass transfer resistance in large molecule analysis. Advances in one-step coating synthesis have produced optimized wide-pore SPPs that enable rapid, high-resolution separations of proteins and monoclonal antibodies, addressing growing needs in biopharmaceutical quality control and research.

Study Objectives and Overview

This work aimed to synthesize and characterize wide-pore SPPs via a single coacervation step, then benchmark their chromatographic performance against other wide-pore SPPs and sub-2 µm totally porous particles (TPPs). Key objectives included examining the influence of pore size, shell thickness and particle diameter on separation quality for large biomolecules.

Methodology

• Particle synthesis: Coacervation polymer coating on Stöber cores, followed by burn-off and sintering to yield a uniform silica shell.
• Physical characterization: Measurement of particle size distribution, shell thickness, surface area (BET), pore size distribution and pore volume.
• Chromatographic evaluation: Reversed-phase LC separations of protein standards, intact IgG1/IgG2, and papain-digested fragments under various gradient, flow rate and temperature conditions.

Instrumentation

• Agilent UHPLC systems with 2.1 × 100 mm columns
• UV detectors set at 215–254 nm
• Column ovens for 40–85 °C operation

Main Results and Discussion

• Pore size effect: Columns with 450 Å pores delivered the sharpest peaks and highest resolution for intact antibodies, outperforming 200 Å and 400 Å counterparts.
• Shell thickness: A 0.25 µm silica shell minimized peak broadening at high flow rates.
• Particle size: 3.5 µm particles balanced backpressure and efficiency better than 2.7 µm cores.
• Ligand selectivity: C4, SB-C8 and diphenyl chemistries provided tunable selectivity for proteins and mAb isoforms. Temperature optimization further refined isoform resolution.
• Carryover: Optimized SPP phases exhibited negligible sample carryover in blank runs.
• Comparison with TPPs: The 3.5 µm, 450 Å SPPs achieved superior peak shape and resolution under lower pressure than sub-2 µm TPP columns.

Benefits and Practical Applications

• High throughput: Rapid gradients (4–12 min) for intact mAb and protein fragments.
• Enhanced resolution: Clear separation of isoforms and low-abundance variants.
• Robust operation: Stable performance at elevated temperatures and flow rates with minimal carryover.
• Bio-pharma utility: Ideal for QA/QC assays, method development and biomarker characterization.

Future Trends and Opportunities

Development of even larger pore diameters (>600 Å), alternative surface chemistries for ion-exchange or hydrophilic interaction, integration with mass spectrometry interfaces, and miniaturized UHPLC formats will expand SPP applications in proteomics, biotherapeutic profiling and personalized medicine.

Conclusion

The one-step coacervation method yields 3.5 µm SPPs with a 0.25 µm shell and 450 Å pores that excel in fast, efficient separations of large biomolecules. These optimized particles outperform other commercial wide-pore SPPs and sub-2 µm TPPs, offering a versatile platform for modern bio-analytical challenges.

Reference

Chen W, Mack A, Wang X. Synthesis and optimization of wide pore superficially porous particles by a one-step coating process for separation of proteins and monoclonal antibodies. J Chromatogr A. 2015;1414:147–157.