IN SEARCH OF THE PERFECT NOTCH: A NOVEL APPROACH TO THE OPTIMIZATION OF DIPOLE EXCITATION WAVEFORMS IN QUADRUPOLE MASS FILTERS

Importance of the Topic

The ability to exclude a defined mass‐to‐charge (m/z) range within a quadrupole mass filter enables higher specificity and sensitivity for tandem MS experiments. Notch filtering reduces interference from co‐eluting analytes and allows simultaneous encoding of multiple precursors, improving throughput and data quality in complex mixtures.

Objectives and Overview of the Study

This study presents a novel computational approach to design dipole excitation waveforms that generate sharp transmission notches in quadrupole mass filters. It aims to:

• Define a target m/z exclusion window (“notch”).
• Optimize amplitudes and phases of multiple sinusoidal dipole excitations.
• Validate the resulting waveforms in realistic simulations.

Methodology

A two‐dimensional quadrupole model with RF confinement was developed. Ions experience radial motion governed by a differential equation incorporating superimposed dipole excitations. Key steps include:

• Representation of the notch by setting excitation amplitude to zero within the target m/z range.
• Superposition of N sinusoidal dipole waveforms with variable amplitude, frequency, and phase.
• Solution of ion trajectories via numerical integration over time.
• Parameter optimization using a Markov Chain Monte Carlo algorithm with simulated annealing to maximize a Gaussian quality metric relative to the ideal notch profile.

Instrumentation Used

• Custom C++ quadrupole simulator tracking ion trajectories.
• SIMIONTM for more realistic physics-based validation.
• Quadrupole configuration: length 130 mm, RF amplitude 300 V, RF frequency 830 kHz, internal radius 5.3 mm.

Main Results and Discussion

The optimisation yields high‐quality notch profiles in simulated data. Various amplitude‐phase solutions achieve the same target window, demonstrating flexibility. Key observations:

• Optimised waveforms reproduce sharp 200–400 Th exclusion in both simple and realistic simulations.
• Multiple parameter sets produce equivalent performance, offering robustness against instrumental variability.
• Continuous phase functions and frequency sweeps show that superposition of discrete dipoles can outperform analytical sweeps in producing steep notch edges.

Benefits and Practical Applications

• Customized transmission profiles for targeted precursor selection in MS/MS.
• Simultaneous encoding of multiple precursors enables data‐independent acquisition strategies.
• Potential to implement complex notch designs, including multiple exclusion windows.

Future Trends and Potential Applications

Future work may explore:

• Limits of edge sharpness and transition tolerance in practical instruments.
• Optimization of waveform record length and apodization to reduce discontinuities.
• Extension to multiplexed notches and adaptive real‐time waveform generation.
• Experimental validation on commercial quadrupole platforms.

Conclusion

A versatile MCMC‐based optimisation framework has been demonstrated for designing dipole excitation waveforms that produce high‐quality notches in quadrupole mass filters. The approach is validated in both idealized and SIMION simulations, offering a powerful tool for enhancing selectivity in tandem MS applications.

Reference

1. Comisarow MB, et al. Chem Phys Lett. 1974;25:282–283.
2. Chen L, et al. Anal Chem. 1987;59:449–454.
3. Feynman RP, Leighton BL, Sands ML. The Feynman Lectures on Physics. Caltech; online edition.
4. Richardson K, Green M, Hughes C. Comparison of product ion specificity in LC‐MS DIA data between MSe and MSe with m/z selective intensity encoding. ASMS Proc. 2022.
5. SIMION. Adaptas Solutions LLC.