Performance Comparison of Binary Ultra High Performance Liquid Chromatography Systems from Multiple Vendors for Methods Which Utilize Long, Shallow Gradients

Importance of the Topic

Long shallow gradients in ultra high performance liquid chromatography are essential for separating complex peptide digests and biomolecules with high resolution. Reliable gradient delivery under high pressure conditions ensures consistent retention times, accurate peak identification, and efficient data generation in research and quality control laboratories.

Objectives and Study Overview

This application note evaluates the retention time reproducibility and gradient formation accuracy of three binary UHPLC systems using a generic peptide mapping method. The goal is to identify differences in performance for methods requiring long shallow gradients and to demonstrate the robustness of each system over multiple injections.

Methodology and Instrumentation

A MassPREP enolase digestion standard was prepared daily and analyzed across eight replicate injections on each system. A 2.1 × 100 mm peptide BEH C18 column operated at 65 °C with a 0.2 mL/min flow rate and a gradient from 1 to 50 percent organic over 88 minutes was used. Detection was performed at 214 nm with data collected at 10 Hz. Fresh mobile phases were pooled and divided to minimize variability.

Used Instrumentation

• ACQUITY UPLC I-Class PLUS System with UPLC TUV detector
• Vendor A binary UHPLC system with diode array detector
• Vendor B binary UHPLC system with diode array detector
• Waters ACQUITY UPLC Peptide BEH C18 1.7 µm column
• Empower 3 CDS and Chromeleon 7.2 data systems

Key Results and Discussion

The ACQUITY UPLC I-Class PLUS System achieved the lowest average retention time standard deviation of 0.012 min (0.7 s) across eight injections. Vendor B showed intermediate performance with a 0.033 min standard deviation, while Vendor A exhibited the highest variability at 0.062 min (3.7 s). Overlaid chromatograms illustrate tight alignment of peaks for the ACQUITY system compared to random shifts on the other systems. Sequential injections on Vendor B demonstrated inconsistent early gradient behavior, leading to peak merging and ambiguous identification.

Benefits and Practical Applications

Superior gradient precision and reproducibility reduce reanalysis, support unambiguous peak tracking, and enhance confidence in quantitation. This is particularly valuable in peptide mapping, glycan analysis, and natural product profiling where minor solvent composition changes impact separation.

Future Trends and Potential Applications

Advances in high pressure mixing and binary pump design will further improve gradient accuracy. Integration with automated sample handling and real time feedback control can enable adaptive method optimization. Expanded applications may include large biomolecule characterization, metabolomics, and multiomics workflows requiring extended shallow gradients.

Conclusion

The ACQUITY UPLC I-Class PLUS System outperformed two other high pressure binary UHPLC systems in retention time reproducibility and gradient delivery accuracy under long shallow gradient conditions. Its consistent performance supports reliable peptide mapping and complex separations over extended analytical campaigns.

References

1. M Swartz I Krull Validation and Peptide Mapping LCGC North America 2007 25 468-475
2. MA Lauber SM Koza EE Chambers Comprehensive Characterization of the N and O-Linked Glycosylation of a Recombinant Human EPO Waters Application Note 720005462EN 2015
3. S Nikles H Monschein H Zou Y Liu X He D Fan A Lu K Yu G Isaac R Bauer Metabolic Profiling of the Traditional Chinese Medicine Formulation Yu Ping Feng San J Pharm Biomed Anal 2017 145 219-229
4. J Simeone P Hong P McConville Performance of the ACQUITY UPLC I-Class PLUS System for Methods Which Employ Long Shallow Gradients Waters Application Note 720006290EN 2018