Software Utilizing Positive and Negative Ion MS2/MS3 HCD and CID Spectra for Improved MSn Lipid Identification

Importance of the Topic

This work addresses the growing demand for comprehensive lipid profiling in biological research and industrial applications. Untargeted lipidomics reveals the diversity and dynamics of lipid species in complex matrices, providing critical insights into metabolic pathways, phenotypic changes, and disease markers. By integrating high-resolution mass spectrometry and advanced data processing, researchers can achieve both deep coverage and structural specificity essential for modern analytical workflows.

Goals and Study Overview

The primary objective was to develop and demonstrate a unified LC-MSn workflow that merges high-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) and collision-induced dissociation (CID) spectral data for enhanced lipid identification. The study focused on total lipid extracts from western corn rootworm larvae, profiling phosphatidylcholines (PC), triacylglycerols (TG), and other lipid classes. By using the Thermo Scientific Orbitrap ID-X Tribrid mass spectrometer and the LipidSearch 4.2 software, the authors aimed to increase annotation confidence, quantify low-abundance species, and uncover biologically relevant lipid isomers.

Methodology and Instrumentation

The analytical strategy combined reversed-phase C30 liquid chromatography with data-dependent MS2 acquisition and targeted MS2/MS3 triggers. Key elements included:

• Chromatography: Thermo Scientific Vanquish system with Accucore C30 column (2.1×150 mm, 2.7 µm).
• Mass Spectrometry: Orbitrap ID-X Tribrid, operating at 120 K resolution for MS1 and 15 K for MSn scans in both positive and negative ion modes.
• Fragmentation Modes: HCD for broad MS2 profiling; targeted CID MS2/MS3 on diagnostic product ions (e.g. m/z 184.07) and neutral losses (fatty acid + NH3).
• Internal Standards: SPLASH LipidoMIX deuterated lipids for estimated quantitation and evaluation of reproducibility.
• Data Processing: LipidSearch 4.2.9 beta with expanded lipid database, improved peak detection, false-positive reduction, and shorthand nomenclature compliant with current guidelines.

Main Results and Discussion

Combining HCD and CID MSn enhanced structural elucidation and isomer discrimination. Highlights include:

• Annotation Depth: Nearly 1 000 lipid species confidently identified across 12 positive and 12 negative runs, with 1 131 CID MS2/MS3 results supplementing 1 522 HCD MS2 spectra.
• Isomer Resolution: MS3 data resolved co-eluting TG 48:1 isomers (14:0_18:1_16:0 vs. 16:0_16:1_16:0) by tracing fatty acid losses and product-ion spectra.
• Phenotypic Differences: Low-abundance PI 36:4 isomers showed significant variations between larval instars and dietary conditions (PI 18:1_18:3 vs. PI 18:2/18:2), revealing developmental and nutritional effects on lipid metabolism.
• Reproducibility: Coefficients of variation below 7 % for labeled internal standards; robust alignment, noise filtering, and quality grading in LipidSearch.

Benefits and Practical Applications

This workflow offers:

• High Confidence: Integrates multiple fragmentation datasets to reduce misannotations and improve confidence scores.
• Comprehensive Coverage: Detects a broad range of lipid subclasses, including phospholipids, glycerolipids, sphingolipids, sterols, and estolides.
• Quantitative Reliability: Utilizes deuterated internal standards for relative and semi-absolute quantitation with excellent reproducibility.
• Versatility: Applicable to diverse sample types—cells, tissues, insects, plasma, and plant extracts—for both discovery and targeted lipidomics.

Future Trends and Potential Applications

Anticipated advances include:

• Machine Learning Integration: Automated spectral interpretation and isomer prediction through artificial intelligence algorithms.
• Expanded Databases: Incorporation of emerging lipid subclasses and modified lipids for expanded structural coverage.
• Real-Time Method Adaptation: Adaptive data-dependent acquisition that tailors fragmentation strategies based on live results.
• Multi-Omics Fusion: Integration with proteomics and metabolomics to yield holistic cellular and phenotypic insights.

Conclusion

The combined HCD-CID LC-MSn workflow on an Orbitrap ID-X platform, coupled with LipidSearch 4.2 software, establishes a powerful approach for untargeted lipidomics. It delivers high annotation confidence, isomer discrimination, and reliable quantitation across complex biological samples. This strategy paves the way for deeper lipidome characterization in research and quality control applications.

References

1. Peake DA, Kiyonami R, Gachotte D, Reid GE, Yokoi Y, Hühmer A. Increased Depth and Confidence of Lipidome Analysis from Insect Tissues using Chromatography Based Methods with High-resolution Orbitrap MSn. ThP 544, 66th ASMS Conference, 2018.
2. Murphy RC. Tandem Mass Spectrometry of Lipids: Molecular Analysis of Complex Lipids. RSC, Cambridge, UK, 2015.
3. Liebisch G, Vizcaíno JA, Köfeler H, et al. Shorthand notation for lipid structures derived from mass spectrometry. J Lipid Res. 2013;54(6):1523–1530.
4. van Smeden J, Boiten WA, Hankemeier T, Rissmann R, Bouwstra JA, Vreeken RJ. Combined LC/MS platform for analysis of all major stratum corneum lipids and profiling of skin substitutes. Biochim Biophys Acta. 2014;1841(1):70–79.